Tuesday, November 15, 2011

You voted for ... both.

Here ends the poll on the school zone aesthetics. Thanks to the 8 readers who participated. I cannot say there is a "clear winner", but globally, the "newer" wood got slight preference as it is more "joyful". But that's for readers alone.

Simultaneously, I got feedback from two graphism artists (including one pixel artist) who didn't exactly "voted" to this poll, and they clearly stated that "the old wood was better, because it looks more like wood". That's something I cannot ignore, so I'm back at world 1-1 : *I* have to make the decision, or to come up with something that would combine the advantages of both. And the picture I just shoot at work might help.


Voilà. Cloture des votes sur un score plutôt mitigé. Si on peut dire qu'une majorité des lecteurs de ce blog ont préféré les nouvelles couleurs, plus vives et plus joyeuses, en revanche, les 2 graphistes qui ont jeté un oeil sont unanimes: l'ancienne version est nettement plus réussie, donnant plus un look "bois". pour ce bois-là, le fond clair est trop gris, et le fond sombre montre trop de contraste -- rien de difficile à ajuster.

Alors je reprends une petite photo du couloir, histoire de me faire un "vrai" raster de bois et de voir si je peux faire une version intermédiaire *aussi* pour le bloc de bois...

1 comment:

PypeBros said...

poll results:
* new&light: 4/8
* new&dark: 1/8
* old&light: 0/8
* old&dark: 3/8